Weighted-Living-Logo for website

Are Catan Dice Weighted? Catan Dice Guide

are Catan Dice weighted Catan Dice Guide

The game Settlers of Catan is an excellent choice for having an enjoyable board game night with your family and friends. Many board games are available, but Catan is among the most popular. The game is a gateway level, so it doesn’t require any experience to play, and it has sold millions of copies.

You trade, build, and settle on Catan during the game to score victory points. Players often experience a less-than-fun experience when their rolls are low. Many players use weighted catan dice to win. Making your desk game stand out can be made easier with weighted dice.

Are Catan Dice Weighted? Catan Dice Guide

What is Weighted Dice?


Weighted dice may be crooked and may be used to delight, confuse, or conquer. Adjusting the weight distribution, you can make a dice land more often on the desired side. Using weighted dice will make your desk game more noticeable and attract more attention.

Are Catan Dice Weighted?

There is always a favourite dice among role-playing game fans. Games with dice introduce the element of chance into the game. Rolling too low, too often, can lead to losing a fight by even the strongest warrior. You need one brick to complete this road, but the dice won’t let you have it. Having such an experience can make some people wish for weighted dice.

Moreover, it’s possible to use weighted dice without being detected scientifically. Would it be possible to make weighted catan dice? There is no doubt that the answer is yes. You can create weighted dice that will not be detectable if you just want a slight advantage over your friend. The method is fairly straightforward.

probabilities or rolling regular dice

Basically, you need to soak the wooden dice overnight in water, and you can make them heavier. As a result of this method, you’ll gain a slight advantage during a game. However, Settlers of Catan is a multiplayer game, so your third 12 might raise suspicions among other players. Are they able to prove that you cheated? Rather than directly confront you, they rely on the scientific method, which is impossible to detect.

Using a case study, I will show that standard scientific tests cannot determine an unfair game. This effectively means that you can’t be scientifically proved to be cheating by your opponent. Methodological defects in current scientific practice lead to this impossibility.

There is almost no chance your friend will detect cheating if you are worried about your friend catching you. Can you explain? According to testing, weighted dice come up with sixes about five per cent more often than fair dice.

Weighted dice and regular dice combinations outcome

The result is about three more sixes than you would expect during the course of a standard game. Do these facts prove that the dice are weighted? That’s unlikely, in my opinion. Calculating p-values is the most common method used by scientists to test hypotheses. The probability of a certain result occurring by chance is expressed as a p-value. What is the likelihood that a fair dice rolls an extra three sixes throughout a typical game?

It is essentially a measure of how likely a false positive will occur. To demonstrate that a result is real, it is necessary to ensure that there are very few false positives. If you want a low p-value, you need a lot of data, but Catan does not provide that opportunity. The p-value of 0.265 can be calculated by adding three sixes to a game of Catan. Therefore, those extra sixes have a 26.5% chance of false positives.

That is just too much of a chance that any reasonable scientist would believe you are cheating on that statistic. The scientist would need to play about five more games to be confident that the dice are weighted. Unless your scientist friends play more than six games together, they cannot prove that you are cheating.

Is it possible to prove that Catan dice are weighted?

A mere observation of dice rolls cannot prove that the dice are weighted. By comparing the dice rolls, you can determine the probability that the true random source would produce outcomes like the dice. The probability never actually reaches zero, even as it gets smaller and smaller.

How do you define fair dice?

In simple terms, a fair dice has the same probability of landing upright on each side. The dice is considered fair if each of its six sides has a probability of 1/6. However, there are several factors to consider here, and the situation becomes even more complex when considering shapes other than a cube.

Are Catan Dice Weighted? – Conclusion

Settlers of Catan is an enjoyable board game with a lot of strategic depth and a fair amount of luck. Each time you play, the board is different, so it has a lot of replayability. Despite being a euro-style game, it has a good amount of player interaction.

You can block other players’ road routes and trade with them. The game is fun to play with friends and family. You want to be in a favourable position whenever playing with friends or family. Weighted dice make this possible. So the answer to the question if catan dice are weighted is purely up to player’s decision, Catan dice typically does not come weighted from the get go.

Mike Horton (head of Weighted Living)

by Mike Horton

Mike is one of the lead editors at Weighted Living and the author of this article. He's become fascinated with weighted products (a bit too much we think) and loves to see all the different ways they can improve our loves. He's written quite a few weighted product guides as well.

Check Out Related Weighted Products