Mayo Clinic Diet vs Weight Watchers (WW) - Which is Better?

Mayo Clinic Diet vs Weight Watchers (WW)

For many people, weight management is vital not just for aesthetic reasons but also for health reasons. Trying to lose weight is much harder than trying to gain it.

Overweight and underweight people are at serious risk of health problems.

Healthy living is the answer to obesity, overnutrition, and eating disorders. To avoid weight gain and ensure fitness, you should follow a strict diet plan and monitor your progress daily.

Two of the most popular programs for promoting a healthy lifestyle are the Mayo Clinic Diet and Weight Watchers (WW).

To help you determine which plan may be best suited for your needs, we have compared Mayo Clinic Diet with Weight Watchers, according to a few features of their products and services.

Mayo Clinic Diet vs Weight Watchers (WW): Summary

Mayo Clinic Diet vs. Weight Watchers (WW)

What is the New Mayo Clinic Diet?

The New Mayo Clinic Diet is a well-balanced eating plan marketed as a weight management plan for life that focuses on weight loss in the long run. Mayo Clinic experts developed the program based on extensive research and clinical experience to help you form easy-to-maintain habits.

This program revolves around the five-tier Mayo Clinic Healthy Weight Pyramid designed to encourage the consumption of nutrient-dense food choices that will leave you feeling satisfied and full. For the diet to be effective, choose nutritious foods and increase physical activity while adapting your lifestyle.

The program is broken into two phases, with the first one focusing on a two-week “Lose It” plan meant to get participants started by reinforcing positive habits. Next comes the “Live It” phase, which encourages you to take steps to overhaul your lifestyle.

The New Mayo Clinic Diet provides many health benefits besides promoting weight loss. Researchers have found that diets that emphasize the consumption of whole foods and limit high sugar and processed foods can reduce the risk of developing various health conditions, such as Type 2 diabetes, heart disease, and certain forms of cancer. Among the best diet programs for 2022, the Mayo Clinic Diet is rated as the number one program by U.S. News & World Report.

What is the WW program? (Weight Watchers)

WW Weight Watchers weight loss program

WW, formerly known as Weight Watchers, has been around for so long that your grandmother likely tried it when she attempted to lose the baby weight. Since founded in the 1960s, WW has amassed hundreds of thousands of subscribers. It all began with Jean Nidtech in Queens, New York, who organized a weekly program for friends to lose weight. Since then, the brand has grown into one of the most dependable on the market. A rebranding took place in 2018, and WW became its name. For better effectiveness, it provided several Weight Watchers plans to its users.

WW aims to offer more than weight loss and is the most comprehensive program.

Your overall health is being addressed renewedly, with a fresh outlook. Therefore, if you choose to join the new Weight Watchers program, you’ll eat well and take care of your body and mind. Every day you will get a certain number of points plus bonus points every week that you can use however you wish. Additionally, there are incentives to earn more points, like drinking more water, eating more veggies, and staying active. This makes it so fun!

Additionally, on every personal plan, you have access to various Zero Point foods. As a result, you can consume these foods as much as you desire without using any points. If you want to fill up your meal, you can also try getting creative and using as many Zero Point foods as you want. By doing this, you will be able to eat more while keeping your PersonalPoint level low. Not only that, you can select other healthy foods as well. I have chicken breast and skinless, boneless eggs as Zero Point Foods on my meal plan!

Mayo Clinic Diet vs. Weight Watchers (WW): How does it work?

How Does the Mayo Clinic Diet Work?

Healthy eating is easy with the Mayo Clinic Diet because it teaches you how to estimate portion sizes and plan meals. This program does not require that you count calories precisely. Instead, you’ll consume tasty foods that will help you lose weight.

Optimistic Mayo Clinic experts designed the Mayo Clinic Healthy Weight Pyramid to help you find calorie-rich foods but filling at the same time. The pyramid’s food groups emphasize health-promoting options. The pyramid recommends eating practically unlimited amounts of vegetables and fruits because they are beneficial to weight loss and health. Basically, it comes down to eating a lot of food from the groups at the base and moving a lot more from the top.

Including physical activity and exercise is a great way to incorporate more physical activity into your day. You can find the right plan for you in the Mayo Clinic Diet. You’re supposed to exercise for at least 30 minutes a day to lose weight and boost your health. Exercises in the book include easy-to-follow walking exercises and resistance exercises that will aid fat loss and improve mental health. The program encourages participants to move more throughout the day, such as taking the stairs instead of an elevator.

When starting a new physical activity program, talk to your doctor or health care provider if you’ve been inactive or if you have a health condition. The average person can start with 5- to 10-minute activity sessions and increase the time gradually.

How does the WW Diet work?

Based on their height, weight, age, and weight loss goals, dieters are allotted a specific number of daily points when they begin the program. The value of PersonalPoints is determined by the amount of calories, sugar, saturated fat, and protein they contain. Some plans provide zero points for lean proteins such as chicken, but there are few or no points for fruits, non-starchy vegetables, and non-starchy vegetables. Moreover, sugary and fatty foods have a higher number of points. However, no food is completely off-limits. As an alternative, dieters can adjust the portions they eat or modify their other meals to still enjoy their favorite foods. On the WW app, users can keep track of how many PersonalPoints they’ve consumed each day.

As an added benefit, members receive an allowance of extra points per week to use on splurges or special occasions. Furthermore, you can rollover up to four daily PersonalPoints into your bank of weekly PersonalPoints. In addition, you can eat more non-starchy vegetables, drink enough water, or stay active to increase your daily PersonalPoints budget.

The PersonalPoints Engine calculates your daily allotment of PersonalPoints based on your age, sex, height, and weight. Men, young people, and those with larger bodies are generally assigned higher daily PersonalPoint budgets. However, women, older adults, and people who are shorter or have a smaller body mass have a lower daily PersonalPoint budget.

Mayo Clinic Diet vs. Weight Watchers (WW): Foods

Mayo Clinic Diet Foods

Based on an expert-endorsed healthy-weight pyramid, the Mayo Clinic Diet manages your energy intake so that you lose weight without feeling hungry. With it, you can eat healthy foods such as fresh produce, protein, low-fat dairy, healthy unsaturated fats, and even take in a small amount of sugar.

The pyramid identifies healthy foods as unprocessed, such as fruits, vegetables, brown rice, oats, nuts, beans, fish, chicken, etc. Dietary guidelines recommend reducing the intake of foods at the top of the pyramid and consuming most foods at the base. The diet allows nearly all food groups, but it discourages the consumption of processed foods, such as snack mixes, cereal bars, packaged foods, soda, flavored yogurt, candy, and foods high in saturated fats. Those who follow it should also reduce alcohol consumption.

WW Foods

WW offers many ZeroPoint foods, which don’t count toward your daily PersonalPoint budget. PersonalPoints Engine determines what foods are ZeroPoint on your plan based on your preferences and needs. Despite this, most of these foods contain high protein levels and limited amounts of sugar.

The WW diet encourages various foods, such as apples, apricots, bananas, berries, broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage, fish, eggs, tofu, beans, lentils, and edamame, nonfat plain yogurt, water, unsweetened tea, etc. WW program participants are not prohibited from eating any foods. However, some foods are higher in points than others, so they should be limited to avoid exceeding your daily PersonalPoint limit.

Mayo Clinic Diet vs. Weight Watchers (WW): Workout Time

Workout Time for Mayo Clinic Diet

At least 30 to 60 minutes of physical activity should be taken each day, but when and how you do this is completely up to you. Mayo Clinic offers tips, from how to sneak more exercise into your daily routine to overcoming physical limitations and obstacles. Anyone seeking a healthy weight-loss program with long-term results can benefit from the Mayo Clinic Diet. However, it is not for someone looking to shed some weight for a beach trip next month. Having a healthy weight and a normal body size is a long-term solution.

Workout Time for WW

Individuals need different amounts of time to reap the benefits of exercise. However, it’s also less about how long you work out and more about how you’re spending that time. The rest intervals between sets will primarily determine the duration of your resistance training workout. You can work out for hours if you take long breaks between sets, but you don’t accomplish much in the actual session.

Additionally, a brief bout of high-intensity interval training can yield remarkable cardiorespiratory benefits in a fraction of the time it takes traditional aerobic exercises.

The CDC’s recommendations for physical activity can be best followed if you know all of these facts. As a general rule, the CDC recommends that adults exercise moderately for at least 150 minutes each week.

You can do an equivalent combination of vigorous and moderate-intensity aerobic activity for 75 minutes a week. It is recommended that aerobic exercise be undertaken in ten-minute segments, at least twice a week.

Mayo Clinic Diet vs. Weight Watchers (WW): Plans

Mayo Clinic Diet Plan

There are various diet programs, with prices ranging from $19.99 to $49.99 per month. Pricing for the monthly plan is $49.99, and it goes down if you sign up for multiple months. For example, a three-month plan costs $39.99 per month, and a six-month plan costs $29.99 per month.

Additionally, a Mayo Clinic digital platform and app, meal plans, and virtual group video sessions with Mayo Clinic doctors provide additional support to participants. Once you sign up, you can browse meal plans and recipes, use real-time tracking tools to keep track of new habits and get fitness plans tailored to your needs.

WW Plan

Conversely, WW programs offer four plan options with varying levels of support. You should consider your lifestyle, wellness goals, weight loss desires, and budget before joining these plans.

The Digital Plan is the most common, least expensive, and best suited to people who prefer to work independently. The WW app gives you access to everything you need anytime, recipes, and a supportive community. Digital plans cost $22.95 per month + $20 to sign up. People who want some guided support and want to work at their own pace will find Digital 360 highly beneficial. Wellness workshops are available live and on-demand, and direct access to coaches for additional assistance and advice. A Digital 360 subscription costs $29.95 per month plus a $20 start-up fee.

With Unlimited Workshops + Digital (or Meetings), you regularly get live support with an experienced coach. The Unlimited Workshop plan costs $44.95 per month plus $20 to get started.

The 1-on-1 Coaching + Digital package offers the most support, providing weekly private 1-on-1 sessions with a coach you’re assigned to. The 1-on-1 Coaching plan is $59.95 per month plus a $20 setup fee.          

Despite WW’s evolution, they are still firm believers that real change can only be achieved with the community’s support. Almost every WW plan incorporates a motivating and accountable element. Studies have shown that WW Digital is the most popular and least expensive plan, but that the extra support and coaching that comes with WW Digital 360 and Workshops enable you to lose weight more quickly and sustainably.

Mayo Clinic Diet vs. Weight Watchers (WW): Which is better for you?

Are you trying to lose weight? Are you looking for more professional guidance? Do you wish to improve your health and happiness? Mayo Diet Clinic is the perfect partner for you! The Mayo Clinic Diet is ideal if you want to lose weight and become healthier.

Mayo Clinic teaches women and men about tracking diet habits and eating healthy portions by considering all foods. Those willing to put some effort into cooking may also benefit from the Mayo Clinic Diet. The diet plan suggests recipes that aren’t complicated but will require some effort. It is not just beneficial to change your usual behavior, but it can also help you become more of a better person.

The Weight Watchers app, on the other hand, provides everything you need to maintain your weight and get healthy. With PersonalPoints, you can keep track of what you eat and maintain weight. The program keeps track of your progress at every step. By attending the meetings and participating in the coaching program, you will receive the personal encouragement you need to stay motivated.

It is now designed as a way to aid in changing lifestyles and eating habits through a holistic, simplified points system. Rather than worrying about what food to eat, you should be concerned with how much food to consume. Therefore, dieters are encouraged to make smart choices and take action to live healthier lives. However, Weight Watchers remains true to its mission: To lose weight, you must not exceed your daily allotted points.

Although both programs offer positive results for losing weight, it is recommended that you seek advice from a medical doctor, registered dietitian, or certified health coach before starting any weight loss program.

Conclusion

Whether you need a long-term or short-term diet, remember that many diets do not work, especially when you’re trying to lose weight. I am not here to endorse fad diets or unsustainable weight loss methods, but I can provide you with information to make an informed decision that suits your nutritional needs, genetic blueprint, budget, and goals.

The Mayo Clinic Diet is a program that helps you adopt healthy new habits and break unhealthy ones to help you reshape your life. You should aim to make simple, pleasurable changes that will lead to a healthy weight that you can maintain all your life.

On the other hand, the WW program is one of the most popular weight-loss programs that allow people to alter their body shape without dieting. Using fiber, fat, and calorie content, WW assigns a value to foods and drinks that promote a healthy lifestyle.

There are many ways to pursue health, so if weight loss is your goal, keep in mind that losing weight does not necessarily mean becoming healthier. Other lifestyle factors such as exercise, sleep, and nutrition also contribute to your overall health. For optimum health, the best diet is the one that suits your lifestyle.

Mike Horton (head of Weighted Living)

by Mike Horton

Mike is one of the lead editors at Weighted Living and the author of this article. He's become fascinated with weighted products (a bit too much we think) and loves to see all the different ways they can improve our loves. He's written quite a few weighted product guides as well.

Check Out Related Weighted Products